Blue Line

‘The Charter still applies’: Canadians urged to monitor civil liberties during pandemic

April 6, 2020  By The Canadian Press

MONTREAL — While Canadians monitor their bodies for signs of COVID-19 symptoms, civil liberties advocates and human rights lawyers are urging citizens to also keep track of the possible erosion of democratic rights.

The ongoing states of emergencies across the country have given authorities sweeping new powers, and police forces have started — or are considering — using cell phone data to track the movement of people. Civil rights advocates say citizens need to remain hyper-vigilant about how authorities are using these new powers, and what kind of legacy will be left once the pandemic is over.

Montreal-based human rights lawyer Pearl Eliadis said despite the emergency orders, “the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms has not disappeared.”

“The government has more leeway to do certain things because of the emergency powers and we should all agree and obey with those, but at the same time, people need to know what their rights are under the act,” she said in a recent interview.

On Friday, Quebec City’s police chief said his officers used cell phone data to track and arrest a COVID-19-infected woman in March who allegedly violated an order to self-isolate. Robert Pigeon told reporters that so-called geolocation is “absolutely at our disposal” to track a suspect.

“We probably had the only case in Quebec of non-cooperation regarding someone infected with the illness,” Pigeon told reporters. “Therefore, we used every means of investigation to localize her.”

Quebec Premier Francois Legault said Friday provincial police had proposed using data from cell phones and other devices to locate people. But, he said, those tracking methods haven’t been authorized for the provincial police — yet.

“In the short term … we don’t have the intention to use (geolocation),” Legault told reporters. “But, if the situation is different in one week or two weeks, will we accept the proposal from the Surete du Quebec? Maybe.”

Provincial police spokesman Guy Lapointe told Montreal’s La Presse on Friday that under the public health emergency, officers do not need a warrant signed by a judge to track people using geolocation. Neither Lapointe nor the Montreal police responded to a request for comment.

A spokesman for Quebec’s public prosecutor’s office would not say whether police had the right to geolocate people without a warrant. Jean Pascal Boucher said Saturday his office is not authorized to give an opinion on matters that have the chance to come before the courts.

Montreal-based defence lawyer Arij Riahi said there are currently many unknowns about how police are using their discretion in issuing fines, limiting travel around the province, as well as how they are collecting cell phone data.

“It has to come with some sort of accountability,” she said, regarding the collection of personal data. “How long will it last? Where will the data be stored? When will it be deleted? The concerns among my criminal defence colleagues is about surveillance creeping in.”

Dominique Peschard, spokesman with a Quebec civil liberties group, La Ligue des droits et libertes, said he doesn’t see why a judge can’t be assigned to review applications by police for cell phone data surveillance — even during the current state of emergency.

He said he has concerns that the use of warrantless surveillance will become more generalized without proper supervision, leaving room for abuse.

The charter, he said, states that citizens’ rights can be limited, “but these limits have to be reasonable and justified in a free and democratic society.”

Eliadis said police in Canada are using facial recognition technology and cyber surveillance “more aggressively now than they were just a few weeks ago.”

She explained that citizens need to be aware of a phenomenon within law enforcement and national security forces that is known as “force drift.”

Force drift can occur, Eliadis said, “when certain extraordinary powers are given, particularly during interrogations, and they spread quickly and the lose their normal bearings and their rules-based bearings.

“And there is a lot of experience with this and I do think people need to be careful.”

– Giuseppe Valiante

This report by The Canadian Press was first published April 4, 2020.

News from © Canadian Press Enterprises Inc., 2020

Print this page


Stories continue below